
This week’s episode opens with a compelling image – the beauty of nature, serene and idyllic as birds take wing. Then their reverie is
interrupted by the sound of a gunshot! One of the birds is killed, delivering a profound message – there is no situation so beautiful that it can’t be ruined by the evils of man.
Oh, wait, maybe that’s not what they meant, since the duck hunter is played by Joe Mantegna, who’s replacing Mandy as the team’s lead
profiler this week. Did they mean for Joe to be introduced representing evil? I’m guessing no.
It seems Joe is a famous former
profiler who’d long ago quit to use his gifts to sell books and get high-paid speaking engagements. If this sounds familiar, it’s because he’s playing a fake version of John Douglas, who would help found the
BSU and then go on to write a series of books about it, while providing the inspiration for basically every
profiler character in fiction. What’s interesting is that the show already has a ‘fake John Douglas’ character, played by Geoff Pierson in the Keystone Killer episode from the first season. Sadly, I guess Geoff
wasn’t a big enough name to build a show around after Mandy had left.
Also interesting? The fact that Joe’s old badge has a photo on it that barely resembles him.
Anyhoo, Joe heads in to meet with the evil AD and demand his old job back. She has no no choice but to agree to Joe’s terms (he wants a job, and nothing else), because he’s so damn famous and skilled that she’d look foolish trying to hold him back when the team needs help.
Personally, I suspect that he’s just joining the team so that he can use its resources to solve his pet case:

Before heading into the office he pockets that charm bracelet. What little girl could it belong to? I’m guessing that his daughter disappeared some years earlier, and he’s been haunted by his failure to catch the culprit all this time.
With any luck, we’ll see if I was right by the end of the episode!
Speaking of episode,
isn’t it about time for a murder?
So this woman in Texas is heading home, and she discovers a missing persons
flyer of herself on her front door:

Alarmed, she calls a detective, who she knows personally, but he assures her that it’s probably just a
pre-Halloween prank. But that night when he swings by the house to check up on her the woman has disappeared - and the inside of her house has been papered with the fliers!
Also the killer left an incredibly creepy mask which suggests that, for a first-time killer he’s got an incredibly elaborate MO.

Time for the opening credits, which I’m actually really interested to see this week.
For the past three episodes since Mandy’s departure Greg has been headlining the show – now that Joe’s going to be in first position, will Greg be fine with going back to second?
Also, did anyone take this opportunity, like
JJ back in season 2, to update their picture in the group shot? We’ll find out after the opening credits!