The episode opens with a murder – a woman is trapped in a trunk with a plastic window, while a man with glasses looks from overhead. He asks her if it’s worse than she imagined, and then shuts her in, places a few magazines atop the trunk to conceal it, and heads back to his desk to do a little reading while she suffocates to death.

So, based entirely on the title and the first minute, I’m guessing this episode is about a crazy man who pretends to be a psychologist specializing in helping people overcome their fears, and then kills his ‘patients’ in the specific way they’re afraid of, because it entertains him to do so. This first woman was claustrophobic, so he sealed her into a coffin to die!
That sounds about right, huh? I’m guessing we can pretty much check out for the remainder of this episode, since it’s all kind of right here in the opening. People turn up dead – he’s had a lot of victims because the
MOs are so diverse, but the team finds a connection,
blach blah blah, victim two gets burned to death because he’s afraid of fire, blah
blach, Reid quotes
Nietsche’s ‘What
doesn’t kill you’ line, blah blah, final woman is saved from spiders and the killer is arrested without incident.
If it
sounds like I’m way too skeptical about this plot, it’s because I am, due to an anecdote that has nothing at all to do with criminal minds, and I’ll share at the end of this review in lieu of a ‘
factcheck’, because this
obviously isn’t based on a true story.
Since my own personal stuff has nothing to do with the show, I’ll endeavour to keep it to myself while I write the review. Hey, here’s a fun game: Let’s guess what the other two fears are going to be covered in the episode with victim 2 and ‘one who gets rescued’!
My guesses? Fire for number 2 (sticking with my gut), but I’m switching the last victim to ‘heights’ because that gives us the chance to have a visually compelling climax where Derek has to edge out onto a girder to save someone who’s to terrified to move.
You know? Just once I’d like someone to be killed by their fear of public speaking. I don’t know how it would happen (other than, you know, audience is so disgusted with the job he's doing that they throw ninja stars), but damn if that
wouldn’t be a hilarious thing to see, right?
Before we get to the opening credits there’s a little plot business to take care of. Mandy’s officially gone, and he took the photos with him. Pick up the slack, Garcia’s map! Now it’s time for them to track down a replacement for the team? Who will it be? I mean, I know it’s Joe Mantegna, I’
ve seen commercials for later episodes (on mute – no spoilers please) – but who is he going to play, and how does he end up on the team?
Then we get the setup for the episode – how did they find out about this difficult-to-catch killer? Someone stumbled onto a mass grave. Oh. That’s disappointing. Even more disappointing? I’
ve already lost the pool – one of the four bodies they found was burned alive, so they’re not going back to that well.
They do offer an explanation for why no one knew a serial killer was working – he had the victims sign pieces of paper that he then wrote letters to their families on, explaining that they were going to be going away and
wouldn’t be talking to anyone for a while. Seems like a pretty simple trick, but it actually worked for ‘
Slavemaster’ for a little while, so that’s got some real-life cred, anyhow.
Will the team be able to catch the killer after one more victim, and save the third? Let’s find out after the credits, together!
But if you don’t have a lot of time, the answer is yes.